Breakdown vs Flashover in Dielectric Strength Testing: Reading the Trip

By | November 11, 2026

In a dielectric strength test, the test set doesn’t tell you what failed. It only tells you the breaker tripped. Everything after that is up to the person at the bench.

Three different events can trip it:

  1. Breakdown. The specimen punctured. This is the result you want.
  2. Flashover. The air or oil around the specimen failed, and current went around the sample instead of through it.
  3. A false trip. Nothing failed. The trip circuit reacted to normal current in the setup.

Only the first one is a valid breakdown value. This article walks through what to do after the trip: how to tell the three apart, why each happens, and how to fix the setup so the next specimen gives a real result.

For the test itself, see our dielectric strength test guide.

Step 1: Look at the Specimen

Take the specimen out and inspect it before anything else.

Signs of Breakdown

  • A hole or puncture through the thickness
  • A carbonized channel through the material

IEC 60243-1 uses exactly this as the test: a carbonized channel or puncture through the specimen means breakdown, not flashover.

Signs of Flashover

  • No puncture through the material
  • Often, tracking marks or soot on the surface, running from the electrode edge toward the specimen edge
  • Occasionally, little or nothing visible, which makes it easy to confuse with a false trip

The Confusing Case: Puncture Just Outside the Electrode

Often the hole isn’t under the centre of the electrode. It sits just outside the edge of the smaller electrode, or outside both if they’re the same size.

That’s still breakdown. A common cause is partial discharge in the surrounding medium at the electrode edge. The discharge starts the failure, and the puncture follows close to where the discharge was. IEC 60243-1 notes that breakdown often lands in this position.

Step 2: If There’s No Puncture, Was It Flashover or a False Trip?

No puncture leaves two possibilities.

Flashover usually comes with a visible or audible discharge around the specimen, and often surface marks. With the same setup, it often happens at a similar voltage on each specimen.

A false trip leaves no marks. It often happens at a low voltage, or at a voltage that changes a lot from specimen to specimen. If you can’t tell which it was, repeat with a higher trip setting: a false trip won’t come back, and a flashover will.

Why False Trips Happen

The trip circuit senses current. Normal currents flow in a test circuit even when nothing is failing:

  • Leakage current through the specimen
  • Capacitive charging current, which rises with voltage and with specimen area
  • Current from corona or partial discharge at the electrode edges
  • Magnetizing current in the test transformer

If the current setting is too low, any of these can trip the breaker before the specimen fails.

The Other Direction: Missed Breakdowns

If the setting is too high, the circuit may not respond properly when breakdown does happen. Current runs longer before the trip, burning a bigger channel through the specimen and pitting the electrodes. Pitted electrodes can then distort results on the next specimens, so inspect and clean them.

What the Standards Say

ASTM D149 is direct about this:

  • The breaker should open within three cycles.
  • The current setting should be high enough to ignore transients like partial discharge, but not so high that it causes excessive burning.
  • The right setting depends on the specimen, so trying more than one setting can help.
  • Changes in current setting and response time significantly affect the results.

In practice: if you’re getting clean-looking specimens with “breakdown” values that jump around, suspect the trip setting first. Record the setting in the report, because it’s part of what defines the result.

Step 3: Fix the Cause of Flashover

Flashover means the path around the specimen is weaker than the path through it. You fix it by making the outside path stronger or the inside path weaker.

Specimen Too Small

The specimen must extend far enough beyond the electrodes that current can’t go around. Both standards simply require specimens large enough to prevent flashover under the test conditions.

For molded thermoplastics, IEC 60243-1 notes that the standard 60 mm × 60 mm plaque may not be enough. In that case, a plate of at least 100 mm diameter is used.

Testing in Air

Air is the weakest common medium. Most solid insulation is much stronger than air, so moderate thicknesses will flash over in air before they puncture.

Move to a liquid. IEC 60243-1 lists:

  • Transformer oil to IEC 60296
  • Silicone fluid to IEC 60836
  • Ester fluid to IEC 61099
  • A suitable casting material

ASTM D149 notes that because flashover must be avoided and discharges before breakdown should be minimized, testing in oil is often preferred or necessary, even for short-time tests.

Specimen Too Thick

Thicker specimens have higher breakdown voltages. At some point the voltage needed to puncture is higher than the voltage the medium can hold around the edge. ASTM D149 notes this typically starts above about 2 mm.

Options:

  • Machine it thinner. IEC 60243-1 allows boards over 3 mm to be machined to about 3 mm on one side, or thinner if needed to avoid flashover. Record the final thickness, and remember that electric strength changes with thickness, so results at different thicknesses don’t compare directly.
  • Machine a recess. ASTM D149 allows a flat-bottomed recess machined or drilled into one or both faces. With unequal electrodes, the larger electrode goes on the machined face.
  • Use seals or shrouds. ASTM D149 allows seals or shrouds around the electrodes, in contact with the specimen, to block the flashover path.

Thin Tapes and Films

Narrow strips flash over around their edges easily. IEC 60243-1 suggests clamping the tape with strips of film overlapping its edges, or using gaskets that leave a small annular gap of 1 mm to 2 mm around the electrode.

Soft Elastomers

Very soft materials like silicone rubber can be hard to test in a liquid. IEC 60243-1 allows embedding them in a casting material as the surrounding medium.

Step 4: Watch the Side Effects of the Fix

Fixing flashover changes the result. That’s normal, but you have to know which way it moves.

Oil vs Air

Breakdown values in oil are often not comparable with those in air. Changing the medium to stop flashover means your new results belong to a different data set. Report the medium every time.

Liquid Permittivity

A liquid with higher permittivity than transformer oil can make the same specimen look stronger. If you swap mineral oil for an ester or other higher-permittivity fluid, expect the numbers to change even though the material hasn’t.

Oil Condition

Oil quality matters. Water, dissolved gas, contamination and dissipation factor can all affect results.

There’s a counter-intuitive effect here. Contamination that lowers the oil’s own strength can raise the measured strength of the specimen. A rising trend in specimen results is not always good news. Check the oil.

For the oil side of things, see our oil breakdown voltage test guide.

Gaskets and Seals

ASTM D149 notes that pressure gaskets used for tests in air can affect the breakdown value. Seals stop flashover, but they also change the field at the electrode edge.

Absorbent Materials

Paper and pressboard soak up oil. Their results depend heavily on how they were dried and impregnated, so the procedure has to spell that out exactly. Otherwise the results won’t repeat.

Step 5: Record It Properly

Flashovers and false trips aren’t results. But they are information.

  • Don’t count a flashover as a breakdown value. It measures the medium, not the material.
  • Don’t count it as a pass. The specimen didn’t withstand that voltage. The test just didn’t reach the material’s limit.
  • Replace the specimen and run a new one after fixing the setup.
  • Note discarded specimens in the report, with the reason (flashover or false trip) and the voltage.
  • Note what changed: new medium, thinner specimen, seals, trip setting.

A report with five breakdowns and three noted flashovers tells the reader more than one with five breakdowns and no history.

Discharges Before Breakdown

Even when the specimen does puncture, partial discharges at the electrode edges often run before it fails. IEC 60243-1 makes two points about this:

  • How intense these surface discharges are, and how long they last, strongly affects the measured strength.
  • The standard methods are generally not suitable for finding a material’s strength without prior discharges.

So a “clean” breakdown result still includes the effect of edge discharges. If your design needs to be free of discharges, you need a different test. See our partial discharge in solid insulation guide.

When Flashover Is What You Want

Sometimes the surface path is the thing being tested.

ASTM D149 can also be used for breakdown along the boundary between a solid and the surrounding gas or liquid. IEC 60243-1 has setups for testing parallel to the laminations of a board:

  • Parallel plates: a strip of the material, 100 mm × 25 mm, clamped edge-on between two plates. The electrodes overlap each edge by at least 15 mm, and their edges are rounded to stop breakdown running edge-to-edge between the plates. If breakdown can’t be reached, the width can be reduced to 15 mm or 10 mm, and the change must be recorded.
  • Taper pins in drilled holes 25 mm apart.
  • Parallel cylinders in drilled holes for very strong boards.

Here the failure path runs through or along the material between the electrodes, by design. The same rules apply: carbonized tracks or punctures mean the material failed.

For surface tracking under contamination, which is a different failure mode, see comparative tracking index.

Safety: Ozone

Any discharge in air or an oxygen-containing atmosphere makes ozone. ASTM D149 flags it as a health hazard at high concentrations. The smell fades with continuous exposure, so you can’t rely on your nose. Where discharges are frequent, use extraction near the test area and monitor ozone levels if the smell persists.

Quick Reference

After the tripMeansDo this
Puncture or carbon channel through specimenBreakdownRecord the value
Puncture just outside the smaller electrode edgeBreakdown (started by edge discharge)Record the value
No puncture, surface marks, repeatable voltageFlashoverDiscard; fix the setup
No marks, low or erratic trip voltageFalse tripRaise the current setting; check leakage
Large burn channel, pitted electrodesTrip setting too highLower the setting; clean electrodes
Flashover causeFix
Specimen too smallLarger specimen (for example, 100 mm plate)
Testing in airOil, silicone fluid, ester or casting resin
Specimen too thickMachine thinner, machine a recess, or use seals
Thin tapeOverlapping film strips or gaskets with a 1 mm to 2 mm gap
Soft elastomerEmbed in casting material

FAQ

How do I tell breakdown from flashover?

Look at the specimen. A puncture or carbonized channel through the material is breakdown. No puncture means flashover or a false trip.

The puncture is outside the electrode. Is that valid?

Yes. Breakdown often happens just outside the edge of the smaller electrode, started by discharges in the surrounding medium. It’s still a puncture of the specimen.

Can I count a flashover as a minimum breakdown value?

No. A flashover measures the medium around the specimen, not the material. Discard it, fix the setup and test a new specimen.

Why do my results change when I switch from air to oil?

The medium changes what happens at the electrode edges, including flashover and discharges before breakdown. ASTM D149 notes that values in oil and in air are often not comparable, so always report the medium.

Why did my results go up when the oil got dirty?

Contamination that weakens the oil can raise the measured strength of specimens. Check the oil’s condition before trusting a rising trend.

What causes the breaker to trip with no visible damage?

Usually the current setting is too low. Leakage, capacitive charging, corona or magnetizing current can all trip a sensitive setting. Raise it, and record the setting you use.

At what thickness should I expect flashover problems?

ASTM D149 notes flashover or heavy surface discharge typically becomes a problem above about 2 mm. It depends on the material’s strength and the medium.

Is the breakdown result “discharge-free”?

No. Edge discharges usually occur before breakdown and affect the value. The standard methods aren’t designed to give discharge-free strength.

Author: Zakaria El Intissar

Zakaria El Intissar is an automation and industrial computing engineer with 12+ years of experience in power system automation, electrical protection, and SCADA systems. He founded InsulationTesting.com to share practical, field-tested guides on insulation resistance testing, equipment, and industry standards. His writing is used by electricians and maintenance engineers worldwide. Based in Morocco.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *