IEC 60243-1 vs ASTM D149: Where Dielectric Strength Results Split

By | November 11, 2026

ASTM D149 says something unusual about itself. It describes itself as similar to the IEC power-frequency method, says all its procedures are included in the IEC method, and calls the differences largely editorial.

That’s true on paper. Both standards apply power-frequency AC to a solid sample until it punctures, and both report kV/mm. But run the same material in two labs, one to each standard on default settings, and you can get two different numbers. Neither lab did anything wrong.

The gap comes from defaults. Each standard leaves a lot open, and fills the gaps in its own way. This article lines the two up point by point. It shows where the defaults differ and how to write a spec so the results match.

For the test itself, start with our dielectric strength test guide.

The Short Version

ItemIEC 60243-1:2013ASTM D149
Frequency48 Hz to 62 Hz60 Hz default; usable from 25 Hz to 800 Hz
Default sheet electrodes25 mm upper on 75 mm lowerType 1: 51 mm opposing cylinders
Electrode edge radius3 mm6.4 mm (Type 1)
IEC-style electrodes available?NativeYes, Type 6
Fast rampShort-time, rapid riseMethod A, short-time
Step test start40% of expected short-time breakdown50% of short-time breakdown
Step durations20 s or 60 s60 s typical; 20 s and 300 s alternatives
Slow ramps120 s to 240 s; 300 s to 600 sMethod C, slow rate-of-rise
Default thickness in the calculationNominalMeasured near the breakdown after the test
Conditioning default24 h at 23 °C, 50% RHSet by the specifying document
Number of breakdowns55
ResultMedianAverage, plus standard deviation

The current editions are IEC 60243-1:2013 and ASTM D149-25.

Split 1: Electrode Size

This is the biggest single source of difference.

IEC default (sheets): a 25 mm upper cylinder on a 75 mm lower cylinder, both with 3 mm edge radii. The stressed area is set by the small top electrode.

ASTM default (Type 1): two opposing 51 mm cylinders, 25 mm thick, with 6.4 mm edge radii. ASTM uses this for sheets, films, boards, molded plastics, glass, mica and ceramics.

The ASTM electrode stresses roughly four times the area. A larger stressed area has more chance of including a weak spot, such as a void, an inclusion or a thin patch. So on the same sheet, Type 1 electrodes tend to give a lower breakdown voltage than the IEC 25 mm top electrode. The effect is strongest on thin films, where local defects matter most.

The Fix: ASTM Has the IEC Electrodes

ASTM D149 lists seven electrode types. Two matter here:

  • Type 2: opposing 25 mm cylinders with 3.2 mm edge radii. This is close to the IEC equal-electrode setup, which needs a fixture holding alignment within 1 mm.
  • Type 6: a 75 mm lower and 25 mm upper cylinder, intended for flat sheet tested the IEC way.

So if you want an ASTM test that compares with IEC data, specify Type 6. That removes the largest difference in one line of the spec.

Other Forms

Material formIEC 60243-1ASTM D149
Tapes, films, narrow stripsTwo 6 mm rods, upper rod 50 g, free to move verticallyType 3: 6.4 mm rods, 0.8 mm edge radius
Molded partsTwo 20 mm spheresType 1 or Type 2 cylinders are common
Filling compoundsTwo 12.5 mm to 13 mm spheres, 1 mm gapType 5: 12.7 mm hemispherical electrodes
Along the surfaceParallel plates, taper pins, parallel cylindersType 7: 150 mm plates

The tape electrodes are close but not identical. The IEC rod is 6 mm, the ASTM rod 6.4 mm, and the edge radii differ. On thin film, small changes in edge geometry can shift results. If two suppliers quote film strength under different standards, treat the numbers as indicative only.

Split 2: Ramp Methods

Both standards offer a fast ramp, a step test and a slow ramp. They line up closely, but not exactly.

Fast Ramp

  • IEC short-time test: voltage rises from zero at a steady rate chosen so breakdown happens within roughly 10 s to 20 s.
  • ASTM Method A: voltage rises uniformly from zero at one of a set of standard rates until breakdown. 500 V/s is the most common. Method A is the default when nothing else is specified.

These are the closest pair. Both target fast, repeatable failure, and both are the usual choice for quality control.

Step Test

  • IEC: start at 40% of the expected short-time breakdown voltage. Hold each step for 20 s (or 60 s in the longer version), then step up.
  • ASTM Method B: start at 50% of the short-time breakdown voltage. Hold each step for 60 s typically, with 20 s and 300 s as alternatives.

The 10-point difference in the starting level means ASTM’s first step is higher. That shortens the test, but on materials sensitive to time under stress, it can also nudge the result. If you want the two to match, specify the starting level as well as the step time.

Slow Ramp

  • IEC: a steady ramp with breakdown in 120 s to 240 s, or a very slow ramp with breakdown in 300 s to 600 s.
  • ASTM Method C: a slow rate-of-rise starting from 50% of the short-time breakdown.

ASTM states that Methods B and C give comparable results. It also says they usually give lower values than Method A and may be more meaningful when comparing materials. IEC makes the same point in its own way: electric strength falls as time under voltage rises.

Split 3: Which Thickness Goes in the Math

kV/mm is breakdown voltage divided by thickness. The two standards default to different thicknesses.

IEC default: nominal thickness (or electrode separation), unless something else is specified. Two other options exist: average thickness, or the thickness measured right next to the puncture.

ASTM default: measure thickness after the test, close to the breakdown point, unless the material specification says otherwise. Measurement follows ASTM D374 at 25 °C ± 5 °C.

On a perfectly uniform sheet, these agree. On a real sheet with thickness variation, they don’t.

Example: nominal 1.00 mm, actual thickness at the puncture 0.92 mm, breakdown at 30 kV.

  • IEC default (nominal): 30 / 1.00 = 30.0 kV/mm
  • ASTM default (measured at puncture): 30 / 0.92 = 32.6 kV/mm

Same specimen, same voltage, about a 9% difference from the thickness rule alone. Punctures tend to happen at thin spots, so the measured-at-puncture value usually reads higher than the nominal one.

For a fair comparison, specify IEC option (c), thickness adjacent to the breakdown. That matches the ASTM default.

Split 4: Statistics

Both standards normally call for five breakdowns. They summarise them differently.

IEC: reports the median of five. If any value is more than 15% from the median, five more are run, and the median of all ten is reported.

ASTM: reports the average, along with a measure of spread, preferably the standard deviation.

One low specimen shows the difference.

Example breakdowns (kV): 28, 29, 30, 31, 20

  • Median: 29 kV
  • Average: 27.6 kV

The weak specimen at 20 kV drags the average down by 1.4 kV. The median barely moves. Under IEC, that 20 kV value is more than 15% below the median, so five more tests are run before the result is reported.

Neither approach is wrong. The median describes the material. The average plus standard deviation shows you there’s a problem with consistency. If you only get one number from a supplier, you’re missing half the picture.

Split 5: Conditioning and Medium

Conditioning:

  • IEC default: at least 24 h at 23 °C ± 2 °C and 50% ± 5% RH, unless the material specification says otherwise.
  • ASTM: the specifying document has to state specimen handling and conditioning.

So an ASTM report can be conditioned any number of ways. Check that it states how.

Surrounding medium:

Both standards allow oil or air.

  • IEC lists transformer oil to IEC 60296, silicone fluids and esters. It warns that a liquid with higher permittivity than transformer oil may give a higher apparent strength. Low-strength specimens can be tested in air, and an oven for hot tests must hold ±2 K.
  • ASTM notes that thicker specimens, usually above 2 mm, may flash over or show corona before breakdown. The remedies are oil immersion, a machined recess, or seals around the electrodes.

Same advice, different defaults. Always state the medium and its type.

What Both Standards Agree On

The common ground is wider than the differences:

  • Waveform. Crest factor between 1.34 and 1.48, which is √2 ± 5%.
  • Source capacity. About 40 mA output is usually enough for the standard electrodes.
  • Purpose. Both say short-time results aren’t a direct measure of how a material will behave in service. They’re for quality control, acceptance and comparison.
  • Thickness effect. Electric strength falls as thickness increases.
  • Puncture vs flashover. Only a puncture through the specimen counts as breakdown.

ASTM puts it strongly: a test that doesn’t state the method, rate, specimen handling, medium, temperature, electrodes and failure criterion doesn’t conform. Whichever standard you use, those are the details that make a result comparable.

Writing a Spec That Matches Both

If you buy material from suppliers who test to either standard, put these lines in the spec:

  1. Electrodes: IEC 25/75 mm, which is ASTM Type 6.
  2. Ramp: short-time, with breakdown in 10 s to 20 s. Or name the step method, the starting level and the step time.
  3. Thickness: measured adjacent to the breakdown. That’s IEC option (c) and the ASTM default.
  4. Medium: name the fluid (for example, mineral oil to IEC 60296) and its temperature.
  5. Conditioning: 24 h at 23 °C and 50% RH.
  6. Results: all individual values, plus the median and the average with standard deviation.

With those six lines fixed, most of the gap between the two standards disappears.

Reading a Datasheet That Doesn’t Say

Many datasheets just say “dielectric strength: 25 kV/mm (ASTM D149).” Assume the defaults:

  • Type 1 51 mm electrodes
  • Method A short-time ramp
  • Thickness measured after the test
  • Average of five

Compared with an IEC 60243-1 default value on the same material:

  • Larger electrodes push the ASTM value down.
  • Measured thickness at the puncture pushes the ASTM value up.
  • An average instead of a median usually pushes it down slightly, if one specimen was weak.

These effects partly cancel, which is why ASTM can call the differences editorial. But the net effect depends on the material and thickness, so you can’t apply a fixed conversion factor. If the comparison matters, ask for a retest under matched conditions.

The same problem shows up with tracking resistance, where IEC 60112 and ASTM D3638 values don’t line up one-to-one either.

Quick Reference

QuestionIEC 60243-1ASTM D149
Standard frequency48–62 Hz60 Hz (25–800 Hz allowed)
Sheet electrodes25 / 75 mm, r 3 mmType 1: 51 mm, r 6.4 mm
Matching electrode–Type 6 (25 / 75 mm)
Fast methodShort-timeMethod A
Step start40%50%
Default thicknessNominalMeasured near breakdown
Default conditioning24 h, 23 °C, 50% RHPer specifying document
Specimens5 (10 if one is 15% off the median)5
Reported valueMedianAverage + standard deviation
Crest factor1.34–1.481.34–1.48
Current edition2013D149-25

FAQ

Are IEC 60243-1 and ASTM D149 equivalent?

They’re technically very close, and ASTM says its procedures are included in the IEC method. But their default electrodes, thickness rule and statistics differ, so default results from each don’t always match.

Which gives a higher dielectric strength value?

It depends. Larger ASTM Type 1 electrodes tend to give lower values. ASTM’s default of measuring thickness at the puncture tends to give higher values. The net effect varies with the material and thickness.

How do I make an ASTM test match IEC?

Use Type 6 electrodes, a short-time ramp, thickness measured next to the puncture, the same medium and conditioning, and report both the median and the average.

Why does IEC use the median?

Because one weak specimen can pull the average down a lot but barely moves the median. IEC adds a rule: if any value is more than 15% from the median, test five more.

What’s the current edition of ASTM D149?

D149-25. Check the edition on any report, as older ones may cite D149-09 or D149-20.

Does ASTM D149 cover DC testing?

No. Both D149 and IEC 60243-1 are AC power-frequency methods. DC is covered by ASTM D3755 and IEC 60243-2.

Is ASTM Method B the same as the IEC 20 s step-by-step test?

Close, but not the same. ASTM Method B usually uses 60 s steps starting at 50%. The IEC version uses 20 s steps starting at 40%. Specify both the starting level and the step time if the two must match.

Author: Zakaria El Intissar

Zakaria El Intissar is an automation and industrial computing engineer with 12+ years of experience in power system automation, electrical protection, and SCADA systems. He founded InsulationTesting.com to share practical, field-tested guides on insulation resistance testing, equipment, and industry standards. His writing is used by electricians and maintenance engineers worldwide. Based in Morocco.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *